*Includes free newsletter

Easy Eggnog Pie Recipe

Eggnog Pie

Today I have a recipe redo for you. Or a throwback or whatever you want to call it. We are looking back at a recipe I shared way back in 2008, which was my first year of blogging.

Looking back at this recipe made me realize how little my kids were when I first started blogging. None of them were teenagers. Now I have three teens. Oh how fast the years have gone.


I shared this eggnog pie back in 2008 because my son loved it. He still loves it. In fact, he still loves eggnog and he still wishes that they would sell it all year long.

If you love eggnog this pie is for you. It is so easy to make. It is not healthy, not healthy at all, but it is really rich and really good. It is one of those pies that is a perfect holiday treat.

Eggnog Pie Recipe

Now I am curious do you agree with my son? Do you love eggnog? Or are you like both my daughters and won’t touch the stuff? I am somewhere in between. I usually have a glass or two each year and that is it. I like it, but don’t love it. What are your thoughts on it?

Lynn's Kitchen Adventures


  1. I think your mom will have to try this when we have company.
    I am not very fond of eggnog because your grand-mother used to give us basic eggnog (no sweetener additives) as a flu recovery medicine/food. Most of the processed commercial eggnog is sickening sweet.

  2. Sherry Cull says:

    I love eggnog!
    I make a eggnog pie and use the Keebler chocolate pie shell!
    It has always been a hit wherever I take it!

  3. I agree with your son! Eggnog should be sold all year long! I buy several containers of it as it is available. I have tried to make it from scratch but it usually doesn’t turn out the best!

Share Your Thoughts