*Includes free newsletter

Eggnog Pie

Eggnog Pie

Eggnog Pie is not the healthiest of pies, but if you like eggnog you will love this pie.

Eggnog Pie

My son loves eggnog. He does not like pasta or rice or many other normal things, but he loves eggnog. Eggnog is a strange thing for a six year old to like. I can’t figure it out, but he does.

Eggnog Pie

In fact, he thinks that stores should sell eggnog year around. He just can’t understand why you can only buy it two months out of the year.

Eggnog Pie

A few years ago I saw several recipes for eggnog pie. After looking at the recipes I came up with a version of my own. We really like this. It is a great pie for the holidays. If you like eggnog you will love this pie.

I will warn you though that this pie is really rich and creamy. A little piece is all you need.

Eggnog Pie

Lynn's Kitchen Adventures


  1. oh.my.goodness. this looks so good!! i love egg nog and so does my hubby! i am so trying the recipe!! thanks!!

  2. Live.Love.Eat says:

    Wow, I never heard of eggnog pie before. Sounds and looks delish! Amazing that your son loves it, true.

  3. Jenn @ Frugal Upstate says:

    MMMM! That looks great. Yankee Bill is another one of those folks who really loves eggnog. I think I put on a couple of pounds last year just from the eggnog (fortified with rum) that he kept feeding me ๐Ÿ™‚

  4. That looks really good. Thanks for the recipe!

  5. Tara @ Feels like home says:

    I love eggnog, so I’m sure I’ll love this recipe! ๐Ÿ™‚ I’ve included it in my weekly Things to Write Home About post.

  6. HI, I’ve made a similar pie for many years. We usually serve it with thawed sweetened raspberries. That is very festive. Thanks for the memories.

  7. Anonymous says:

    I’ll bet this would make a really good cheesecake pie. Maybe even use cheesecake pie filling.

  8. Great recipe, and looks pretty easy, too. Unlike with your son I can’t get anyone to touch eggnog except myself. I buy a half gallon every year and have to work to down it all before it goes bad. Putting it in a pie might be a good way to get some of my family members interested. Thanks for the great idea.

Share Your Thoughts